The stacking reflex
The scenario is a common one. Someone starts with an S&P 500 fund, which tracks large U.S. companies. Then comes a U.S. technology sector fund, because the sector is rising. Then a total world stock fund, so as not to bet everything on the United States. Then a U.S. small-cap fund, a Europe fund, an emerging markets fund. A few months later, the 401(k) or brokerage statement shows eight lines, and the feeling that goes with them: "I am diversified."
Eight lines are not eight bets. The useful question is not how many funds you own, but how many truly different movements your savings actually follow. And that question has an answer in numbers.
What the correlations say
Correlation measures how closely two lines move together, day after day. It runs from 1, two lines that always rise and fall in step, down to 0, no link at all, and on to negative values, for moves in opposite directions. Here is the correlation of daily moves for widely held U.S.-listed funds, over the window from January 11, 2024 to October 1, 2026:
- An S&P 500 fund and a total U.S. stock market fund: 0.99.
- A total U.S. stock market fund and a total world stock fund: 0.96.
- An S&P 500 fund and a Nasdaq-100 fund: 0.94.
- An S&P 500 fund and a U.S. technology sector fund: 0.89.
- An S&P 500 fund and a U.S. small-cap fund: 0.81.
- An S&P 500 fund and a Europe fund: 0.70.
- An S&P 500 fund and an emerging markets fund: 0.68.
- An S&P 500 fund and a U.S. bond fund: 0.20. An S&P 500 fund and a gold fund: 0.18.
Every line of this list above the last one pairs stock funds only. Between them, the correlation never falls below 0.68, and for most of them it is above 0.9. Only the last two funds, a U.S. bond fund and a gold fund, live a life of their own. A total world stock fund today is roughly two-thirds U.S. stocks; a U.S. technology sector fund is almost entirely American. Owning them next to an S&P 500 fund amounts to owning the same thing twice under a different name.
Counting independent bets
There is a simple way to sum all of this up in one figure: the number of independent bets. Take the makeup of the allocation, the volatility of each line and every correlation between them, and compute how many truly distinct sources of risk carry it. An allocation whose lines all move together counts as one bet. An allocation whose risk is split evenly across three unrelated movements counts as three.
Applied to the eight funds of our scenario, an S&P 500 fund, a Nasdaq-100 fund, a total U.S. stock market fund, a total world stock fund, a U.S. technology sector fund, a U.S. small-cap fund, a Europe fund and an emerging markets fund, the measure comes out at 1.05 independent bets. Eight lines, one bet. Three funds that all track the S&P 500 come out at exactly 1.00: the way the money is split among them changes nothing. For comparison, a measurement example with five lines, a total U.S. stock market fund, an international ex-U.S. stock fund, a U.S. bond fund, a gold fund and a U.S. real estate fund, comes out at 1.69.
These numbers are neither good nor bad. They describe. Someone whose goal is to follow the global stock market, and nothing else, has sound reasons to own a single bet. The problem is not the number; it is believing you own eight bets when you own one.
Why the three axes overlap
Many account statements and online tools present an allocation along three axes: by sector, by region, by asset class. Each axis is accurate on its own. The trap comes from stacking them. Technology is a sector, but in practice it is also a region: the United States. Global stocks are an asset class, but two-thirds of them sit in that same region. When one fund is stacked on each axis, it feels like covering three dimensions, while in fact the same ground is covered three times.
That is why the Bubble Watch Compass and the free tool never ask for a breakdown by axis. They start from the lines actually owned, measure how those lines move relative to one another, and let the overlap show up on its own, in the correlation matrix and in the number of independent bets.
Measuring it on your own lines
The free tool computes the number of independent bets of an allocation you enter, in dollar amounts or in percentages, with no account and no email. The computation runs in your browser; nothing is sent anywhere. It covers U.S.-listed funds, and its full method is published on its method page.
Subscribers to The Compass plan get the same measure on the allocations saved in My allocations, with the history of the number over time and the risk share of each line, that is, the share of total variance it carries.
What this number does not say
The number of independent bets describes the recent past, over a given window. It describes the past, not the future. Correlations move, and they tend to rise when markets fall: lines that looked independent start falling together. A reading of 1.7 today does not mean a reading of 1.7 tomorrow.
Nor does it say anything about what fits your situation, your time horizon or the swings you can live with. What is described here is a measure, not a model, a target or a suggestion. Bubble Watch is not a registered investment adviser. We show how to count; what you do with the count belongs to you.
Sources and method
- Correlations and volatilities computed on daily log returns, adjusted prices, from January 11, 2024 to October 1, 2026, using public market data (181 U.S.-listed funds and securities).
- Number of independent bets: the effective number of independent sources of risk in an allocation, computed from the decomposition of its covariance matrix, with the full method on the method page of the free tool.